ATX DECK & PATIO

Should You Replace or Repair Your Old Deck?
A Cost Comparison

Your practical guide to making the right investment for your home in Austin, TX
If you're a homeowner in Austin, TX staring at a weathered, splintered, or sagging deck, you're probably asking the big question: Should I repair it — or just tear it down and replace it?
The answer depends on several key factors, including cost, condition, material, and your long-term plans for the home. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the pros, cons, and price comparisons of deck repair vs. full replacement — with specific insight into what makes sense in the Central Texas climate.

1. Evaluate the Condition of Your Existing Deck
Before jumping into estimates, take a closer look at the structural and surface conditions of your deck.

🔍 Signs Your Deck Might Just Need Repair:A few cracked or rotted boards
Slight warping or cupping in isolated areas
Loose railings or steps
Peeling stain or faded color
Framing and posts still feel solid
Signs It May Be Time to Replace:Widespread rot in the support structure or joists
Posts shifting, sinking, or leaning
Deck feels unstable or soft underfoot
Extensive termite damage or rusted hardware
You’ve repaired the same areas more than once

2. Cost Comparison: Repair vs. Replace Typical Deck Repair in Austin, TX:

Minor surface repairs (replace 5–15 boards): $800–$2,000
Structural repairs (joists, framing): $1,500–$3,500
Staining & sealing: $600–$1,200
Total estimate: $1,500–$5,000

Deck Replacement in Austin, TX:Demo and disposal: $1,000–$2,000
New pressure-treated wood deck (300 sq. ft.): $8,000–$12,000
New composite deck (300 sq. ft.): $12,000–$18,000
Permits, design, railings: additional $2,000–$4,000
Total estimate: $10,000–$20,000+

Option	Pros	Cons
Repair	Lower upfront cost, quicker, keeps existing structure	May be temporary, limited design change
Replace	Brand new structure, updated style, longer lifespan	High upfront cost, longer timeline

4. Austin Climate Considerations
Central Texas is tough on decks:
Intense sun causes fading, warping, and splitting
Rain and humidity accelerate wood rot and mold
Insects and termites target older wooden frames
If your current deck was built over 15 years ago using untreated wood or lacks joist tape protection, full replacement may be a smarter long-term move.

5. When Repair Makes Sense
Repairing your deck can be the right call when:

The framing is still solid and level
Damage is cosmetic or limited to a few areas
You’re staying in the home short-term
Budget is tight and you need a 2–5 year solution

6. When Replacement Is the Better Investment
Choose replacement if:

The deck is over 15–20 years old
You want to upgrade to composite or low-maintenance material
The structure has rot, unsafe posts, or movement
You’re renovating your outdoor space for long-term resale value

Our Recommendation
At ATX Deck & Patio, we help homeowners assess whether repair or replacement will serve them best — practically and financially.
We’ll inspect your deck, check joist and post integrity, and help you calculate the true long-term value of both paths. In many cases, a smart partial rebuild + refinishing can save thousands and still extend the life of your deck by 5+ years.

📍 Serving Austin, Round Rock, Cedar Park, Lakeway and more.